Archive for Historical

Lisa

Matas, C.  (1987).  Lisa.  Scholastic Canada.

Age range 11 and up

Award: Geoffrey Bilson Award for historical fiction for young readers, 1988

5 out of 5 stars

This book tells the story of Lisa, a young woman living in Denmark during the years of Nazi occupation.  This book describes her life as she and her family join the resistance to the German occupation.  This book has some really heartbreaking moments.  At one point Lisa’s father comes home from work (he is a surgeon) and everyone has been gunned down by the Nazis, including a woman who has just given birth.  Despite the tragedy all around them the family still tries to make life enjoyable while fighting the occupation.  The family quickly gathers new members, Suzanne and baby Sarah, as their own families are killed.  The book culminates in a great escape of many Jewish people from Denmark into Sweden.

The story is told in brief narratives, like postcards from the war.  Large gaps of time are left between chapters.  At first I didn’t like this, I wanted more detail, but as the story progresses you get used to the skipping pace. 

I think this book is excellent quality for any reader.  It personalizes history as a good historical novel should do and it doesn’t romanticize it.  This book would also be great for a reluctant reader because it is very gripping and easy to get through.

Kate

Comments (1) »

Troy

Geras, A.  (2002).  Troy.  Harcourt. 

 4 out of 5 stars

Age range 14-16

The second book I read for this class is “Troy” by Adele Geras.  This book, as the title indicates, tells the story of the fall of Troy.  It is told mainly through the eyes of four teenagers as well as some of the other people of Troy.  Actually this book did make me remember my Greek and Roman mythology class in my undergrad because the story was in a way reminiscent of the classics.  It was fraught with love triangles, tragedy and gods walking among the people creating havoc where they went.  Overall though I found this book frustrating because everthing was so mixed up between the characters.  The love in the story seems almost always to be unrequited and no one ends up happy, which I suppose is natural for a story set in the middle of a long drawn out war.  For my tastes though I couldn’t help but wish that someone would love the person that loved them or that Helen and Paris just hadn’t been so stupid in the first place.  I did find my self rooting for Troy though, in that while I knew it would end badly I kept hoping it wouldn’t.

Kate

Leave a comment »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.